Different Strategy Playbooks for Digital Platform Complementors
Philipp Hukal, Irfan Kanat, Hakan Ozalp
This study examines the strategies that third-party developers and creators (complementors) use to succeed on digital platforms like app stores and video game marketplaces. Based on observations from the video game industry, the research identifies three core strategies and explains how they combine into different 'playbooks' for major corporations versus smaller, independent creators.
Problem
Third-party creators and developers on digital platforms face intense competition in a crowded market, often described as a 'long tail' distribution where a few major players dominate. To survive and thrive, these complementors need effective business strategies, but the optimal approach differs significantly between large, well-resourced firms (major complementors) and small, independent developers (minor complementors).
Outcome
- The study identifies three key strategies for complementors: Content Discoverability (gaining visibility), Selective Modularization (using platform technical features), and Asset Fortification (building unique, protected resources like intellectual property). - Major complementors succeed by using their strong assets (like established brands) as a foundation, combined with large-scale marketing for discoverability and adopting all available platform features to maintain a competitive edge. - Minor complementors must make strategic trade-offs due to limited resources. Their playbook involves grassroots efforts for discoverability, carefully selecting platform features that offer the most value, and fortifying unique assets to dominate a specific niche market. - The success of any complementor depends on combining these strategies into a synergistic playbook that matches their resources and market position (major vs. minor).
Host: Welcome to A.I.S. Insights, powered by Living Knowledge, where we translate complex research into actionable business strategy. I’m your host, Anna Ivy Summers. Host: Today, we're diving into the hyper-competitive world of digital platforms. Think app stores, video game marketplaces, even streaming services. How do creators and businesses actually succeed there? Host: We'll be unpacking a fascinating study from the MIS Quarterly Executive titled "Different Strategy Playbooks for Digital Platform Complementors." It examines the strategies that third-party developers, or 'complementors', use to thrive, and finds that it’s not a one-size-fits-all approach. Host: To help us understand this, we have our expert analyst, Alex Ian Sutherland. Alex, welcome. Expert: Great to be here, Anna. Host: So, Alex, let's start with the big picture. Why is this topic so critical for businesses today? What's the core problem this study addresses? Expert: The problem is visibility and survival. Any business that has launched an app or product on a platform like the Apple App Store or Steam knows the feeling. You're competing against millions of others in what's often called a 'long tail' market. Host: And that means a few huge blockbusters get all the attention, while everyone else fights for scraps in that long tail. Expert: Exactly. A massive company like a major game publisher has vast resources, marketing budgets, and established brands. But a small, independent developer has none of that. The study highlights that these two groups—what it calls 'major' and 'minor' complementors—simply cannot use the same strategy to win. Host: It makes sense they'd need different approaches. How did the researchers go about figuring out what those successful approaches are? Expert: They did a deep dive into the video game industry. It's a perfect laboratory for this because it has both multi-billion-dollar franchises and tiny, one-person indie studios competing on the same platforms, like Steam. By observing what worked for both, they were able to identify universal strategic pillars. Host: And what are those pillars? What are the key findings? Expert: The study identified three core strategies that everyone needs to think about. The first is **Content Discoverability**—basically, how do you get seen? The second is **Selective Modularization**, which is about how you use the technical features and tools the platform gives you. Host: Like achievements on a gaming platform or integrating with Apple's specific iOS features? Expert: Precisely. And the third, which is crucial, is **Asset Fortification**. This means building and protecting your unique resources—things like your brand, intellectual property, a unique art style, or a powerful algorithm. Host: So everyone uses these three strategies, but the magic is in *how* they combine them into a 'playbook' that fits their size and resources. Expert: That's the key insight. For major players, like the publisher of a huge game like Call of Duty, their playbook starts with Asset Fortification. They leverage their massive, pre-existing brand. Then they pour hundreds of millions into marketing for Discoverability and use *all* the platform's technical features to meet user expectations and stay ahead. Host: It's a strategy of scale and dominance. What about the little guy, the minor complementor? Expert: They have to be much more strategic. Their playbook is about making smart trade-offs. For Discoverability, they can't afford Super Bowl ads, so they rely on grassroots efforts—building a community on social media, getting influencers to notice them. Host: And for the technical features? Expert: They are selective. They only integrate the platform features that offer the most value for their niche, rather than trying to do everything. And their Asset Fortification isn't a global brand; it's about creating something so unique for a specific niche that it's hard to copy, defending their small piece of the market. Host: This brings us to the most important question for our audience: why does this matter for my business? What are the practical takeaways? Expert: The biggest takeaway is that you can’t succeed with random tactics. You need a coherent playbook where all three strategies—discoverability, modularization, and assets—work together synergistically. And that playbook must be honest about your resources. Host: So if I'm a small business owner launching an app, what's my first step? Expert: First, define your defensible asset. What makes you unique and hard to copy? Is it a novel feature, a specific design, a connection to a niche community? Fortify that first. Then, build your discoverability strategy around that niche. Engage with that community directly. Don't try to be everything to everyone. And finally, be very picky about the complex technical features you add; only choose those that directly enhance your unique asset. Host: So it's about focus, not firepower. And for larger companies? Expert: For major companies, the lesson is not to become complacent. Your primary asset is your brand and existing user base. You must continuously invest in both large-scale marketing and the latest platform technologies, because your users expect it. Your playbook is about reinforcing your market leadership at every turn. Host: It’s fundamentally about knowing who you are in the market—a major player or a niche challenger—and executing a playbook that fits that identity. Expert: Exactly. A small developer trying to act like a huge corporation will burn through their cash and disappear. It’s about playing your own game. Host: Fantastic. So to summarize for our listeners: Success on crowded digital platforms isn't about luck, it's about having the right strategic playbook. Host: That playbook must combine three key elements: getting seen (Discoverability), using the platform's tech (Modularization), and protecting what makes you unique (Asset Fortification). Host: And the right combination depends entirely on whether you're a major player leveraging scale or a minor player dominating a niche through clever trade-offs. Host: Alex, thank you for breaking this down for us with such clarity. Expert: My pleasure, Anna. Host: And thank you for tuning into A.I.S. Insights, powered by Living Knowledge. Join us next time as we uncover more research that can reshape your business.
digital platforms, platform strategy, complementors, strategy playbooks, video games industry, long tail