Mapping Digitalization in the Crafts Industry: A Systematic Literature Review
Pauline Désirée Gantzer, Audris Pulanco Umel, and Christoph Lattemann
This study challenges the perception that the craft industry lags in digital transformation by conducting a systematic literature review of 141 scientific and practitioner papers. It aims to map the application and influence of specific digital technologies across various craft sectors. The findings are used to identify patterns of adoption, highlight gaps, and recommend future research directions.
Problem
The craft and skilled trades industry, despite its significant economic and cultural role, is often perceived as traditional and slow to adopt digital technologies. This view suggests the sector is missing out on crucial business opportunities and innovations, creating a knowledge gap about the actual extent and nature of digitalization within these businesses.
Outcome
- The degree and type of digital technology adoption vary significantly across different craft sectors. - Contrary to the perception of being laggards, craft businesses are actively applying a wide range of digital technologies to improve efficiency, competitiveness, and customer engagement. - Many businesses (47.7% of cases analyzed) use digital tools primarily for value creation, such as optimizing production processes and operational efficiency. - Sectors like construction and textiles integrate sophisticated technologies (e.g., AI, IoT, BIM), while more traditional crafts prioritize simpler tools like social media and e-commerce for marketing. - Digital transformation in the craft industry is not a one-size-fits-all process but is shaped by sector-specific needs, resource constraints, and cultural values.
Host: Welcome to A.I.S. Insights — powered by Living Knowledge. I’m your host, Anna Ivy Summers. Today, we’re challenging a common stereotype. When you think of the craft industry—skilled trades like woodworking, textiles, or construction—you might picture traditional, manual work. But what if that picture is outdated?
Host: We're diving into a fascinating study titled "Mapping Digitalization in the Crafts Industry: A Systematic Literature Review." It explores how craft businesses are actually using digital technology, and the findings might surprise you. Here to unpack it all is our analyst, Alex Ian Sutherland. Alex, welcome.
Expert: Thanks for having me, Anna. It’s a pleasure.
Host: So, Alex, let’s start with the big problem. Why did a study like this need to be done in the first place? What’s the common view of the craft sector?
Expert: The common view, and the core problem the study addresses, is that the craft and skilled trades industry is a digital laggard. It's often seen as being stuck in the past, missing out on the efficiencies and opportunities that technology offers.
Host: And that creates a knowledge gap, right? We assume we know what's happening, but maybe we don't.
Expert: Exactly. This perception isn't just a stereotype; it affects investment, policy, and how these businesses plan for the future. The study wanted to move past assumptions and create a clear map of what’s really going on. Are these businesses truly behind, or is the story more complex?
Host: So how did the researchers create this map? What was their approach?
Expert: They conducted what’s called a systematic literature review. In simple terms, they cast a very wide net, initially looking at over 1,500 sources. They then filtered those down to the 141 most relevant scientific papers and real-world practitioner reports to analyze exactly which digital technologies are being used, by which craft sectors, and for what purpose. It's a very thorough way of getting a evidence-based overview of a whole industry.
Host: That sounds incredibly detailed. So, after all that analysis, what did they find? Was the stereotype true?
Expert: Not at all. The biggest finding is that the craft industry is far from being a laggard. Instead, it's actively and strategically adopting a wide range of digital technologies. But—and this is the crucial part—it's not happening in a uniform way.
Host: What do you mean by that?
Expert: Well, the level and type of technology adoption varies hugely from one sector to another. For example, the study found that sectors like construction and textiles are integrating quite sophisticated technologies. Think AI, the Internet of Things, or Building Information Modeling—what's known as BIM—to manage complex projects.
Host: Okay, so that’s the high-tech end. What about more traditional crafts?
Expert: They’re digitizing too, but with different goals. A potter or a bespoke furniture maker might not need AI in their workshop. For them, technology is about reaching customers. So they prioritize simpler, but very effective, tools like social media for marketing and e-commerce platforms to sell their products globally. It's about finding the right tool for the job.
Host: That makes a lot of sense. The study also mentioned something about "value creation." What did it find there?
Expert: Right. This was a key insight. The analysis showed that nearly half of the businesses—about 48% of the cases—were using digital tools primarily for value creation. This means they are focused on optimizing their internal operations, like improving production processes or making their workflow more efficient. They are using technology to get better at what they already do.
Host: This is such a critical pivot from the old stereotype. Alex, this brings us to the most important question: Why does this matter for business? What are the practical takeaways for our listeners?
Expert: There are a few big ones, Anna. First, for anyone in the tech sector, the takeaway is: don't overlook so-called "traditional" industries. There are massive opportunities there, but you have to understand their specific needs. A one-size-fits-all solution won't work.
Host: So, context is everything.
Expert: Precisely. The second takeaway is for leaders in any industry, especially small and medium-sized businesses. The craft sector provides a masterclass in strategic tech adoption. It’s not about using tech for tech's sake; it's about choosing tools that enhance your core business without compromising your brand's authenticity.
Host: I see. So it's about using technology to amplify your strengths, not replace them.
Expert: Exactly. And the final, more strategic point is about balance. The study found many businesses focus technology on internal efficiency, or value creation. That's great, but there's a risk of neglecting other areas, like customer interaction. The lesson here is to ask: are we using technology across the whole business? To make our products, to market them, and to build lasting relationships with our customers? A balanced approach is what drives long-term growth.
Host: That's a powerful framework for any business leader to consider. So to recap: the craft industry is not a digital dinosaur, but a diverse ecosystem of strategic adopters. The key lesson is that digital transformation is most successful when it’s tailored to specific needs and values.
Host: Alex, this has been incredibly insightful. Thank you for breaking down this study for us.
Expert: My pleasure, Anna. It was great to be here.
Host: And thank you to our audience for tuning in to A.I.S. Insights — powered by Living Knowledge. Join us next time as we uncover more insights from the world of business and technology.
crafts, digital transformation, digitalization, skilled trades, systematic literature review